Many images of planets have been manipulated. So have we seen their true colors? Not always it turns out.
These days, we’re used to seeing pictures of planets sent back by spacecraft. Some pictures look colorful, others less so. But do they show what each planet really looks like?
The short answer to this is “sometimes”, because some planets are genuinely quite colorful. Others are surfaced by rock that is almost entirely grey, and if you come across a picture of these looking colorful you can be pretty sure that the image has been manipulated in some way. Usually it’s a way of exaggerating subtle differences that human eyes are not good at seeing without help.
Anyone who has used a smartphone to take photos has probably stumbled upon various options to exaggerate or tone down the color. Similar techniques are routinely used for processing images sent back by spacecraft, almost always to exaggerate color rather than to make it more subtle.
But a camera on a spacecraft rarely sees colors in the same way as the human eye. For example, the red, green and blue components are usually recorded separately, transmitted to Earth as three separate black-and-white images and combined in color only for display purposes. How the colors come out is bound to be at least subtly different from the ways your eyes would perceive the same view.
What’s more, the colors on an image don’t necessarily correspond to the original colors, even if there has been no attempt to exaggerate them. In principle, a spacecraft camera can record in any part of the light spectrum. When one of the channels lies beyond the visible range, such as in ultraviolet, we still have to use either red, green or blue to display it. That means the resulting picture is “false color”, which might then be further exaggerated.
The giant planets
Jupiter famously has a “Great Red Spot”, a giant oval storm system. While the more subtle colors elsewhere in Jupiter’s clouds may be largely due to the cloud-tops being seen through different depths of transparent atmosphere, the clouds in the spot itself are stained red by an unknown contaminant. Candidates include phosphorous, a sulfur compound, and complex organic molecules.
Jupiter’s Great Red Spot in natural color, by NASA’s Galileo orbiter NASA/JPL/Cornell University
Jupiter’s propensity for strong colors is shared by its innermost large moon, Io. Here, frequent explosive volcanic eruptions shower the ground with sulfur and sulfur dioxide – making the globe look like a yellow pizza, scattered with black “olives” that are in reality patches of lava that are too fresh to have picked up a yellow stain yet.
Left: Io in natural color. Right: Europa, in exaggerated false color to accentuate the difference between ‘clean’ ice (blue) and ‘dirty’ ice (red). NASA/JPL/University of Arizona/DLR
In contrast, the next moon out, Europa, has a surface made of frozen water. This is strongly reflective, making it bright but not very colorful. Most color images of Europa that you are likely to come across are rendered in exaggerated and false color.
Saturn has more muted colors than Jupiter, despite having a similar atmosphere. It’s natural color is only vaguely yellow – any pictures you see of it looking strongly colored are either false color or exaggerated color.
Saturn by NASA’s Cassini orbiter. This is a false color image recorded using three infrared wavelengths, and shows patterns of thermal emission rather than reflected sunlight. NASA/JPL/ASI/University of Arizona
Uranus and Neptune are also hidden by an immensely deep atmosphere. To our eyes, Uranus looks naturally green and Neptune blue, because the tops of their clouds of condensed methane are seen through a great depth of methane gas that filters out the red component of sunlight so that only green-blue light makes it down to the clouds and back out. There’s not much color variation though; the highest clouds look white but everywhere else is blue or green.
A natural colou view of Neptune by NASA’s Voyager 2. NASA/JPL
Two false-color views of Uranus, the first using 3 wavelengths of near infrared light, the second in visible light. Lawrence Sromovsky, University of Wisconsin-Madison/W.W. Keck Observatory
The rocky planets
Mars is aptly referred to as “the Red Planet”. The iron in its rock and dust has largely been turned to iron oxide, or rust. Consequently, Mars looks red to the unaided eye if you see it in the sky, it looks red from orbit, and it looks red as seen by rovers on the ground. Here the debate is whether to render colors as they “really” look or as they would look if the quality of the light were the same as on Earth.
Three versions of the same view on the surface of Mars from NASA’s Curiosity rover. Left: unprocessed. Middle: adjusted to how human eyes would see it. Right: how it would look under Earth-like lighting conditions (note how the color of the sky has changed) NASA/JPL-Caltech/MSSS
Venus is swathed in dazzlingly white clouds and the surface has been visited only by handful of Soviet landers. The dense clouds allow only a dull reddish glow to reach the ground, so everywhere looks orange. But the rocks themselves are really a drab grey kind of lava.
The cloud tops of Venus in natural color, but with the brightness reduced and the contrast stretched to reveal structure. NASA/Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory/Carnegie Institution of Washington
The surface of Venus by the Venera 13 lander. The top view is natural color, the lower view is how it would look with the same sunlight as on Earth. NASA
Mercury is an airless world made of drab, dark grey rock with just a hint of redness. It reflects only about 7% of the sunlight falling on it, which is only slightly more than coal would, but it is three times closer to the sun than the Earth is, where the intense sunlight would make it look pretty bright even without adjusting the image brightness. However, to tease out the color variations that lurk in Mercury’s landscape features, it is common practice to use false color in a way that basically boosts the very subtle natural color differences until they are glaringly obvious.
Don’t think of this as cheating. It is revealing truths about a world that you’d be able to see if your eyes and brain had evolved there, in order to maximise the available information.